With Child, Without is a heartbreaking album about pregnancy loss, infertility and IVF, slightly mitigated by the knowledge that Lucy Claire eventually gave birth. While parenthood may balance sorrow, it does not diminish it, a hard teaching brought to the fore through these thoughtful, intuitive pieces.
The liner notes are exquisite, an example of the artist’s courage to be vulnerable in a public setting. The sequencing is not linear, but each track explores a different aspect of emotion of this five-year journey. One can hear the aching in the chords, encounter the “time suspension” in the background drones, sense the yearning in the notes. How does one go one after one loss to try again and again? As “Fifty-Two Moons” delineates, the cycles can seem never-ending, waiting for a change that may or may not come. The violin of the title track strikes at the heart of sorrow. “Written in the aftermath of an ectopic pregnancy loss. The piece inhabits a threshold between presence and absence; between having been pregnant and returning home without a child.”
Claire begins the next piece on piano, alone; friends enter slowly to keep her company. The album remembers both the stillness and the solace. “Adrift” and first single “Hollow” amplify the sense that something is missing: not only a life but bearings. How does one shift from the identity of mother to mourner? How can land be found?
The ache of losing a child before birth is unlike any other. Only one person has truly known this child; there are no testimonies from family members and friends. In a similar fashion, “Rupture” focuses on the sounds of a hospital at night, another experience that can seem incredibly solitary and impersonal. Fortunately Claire has others to help her through, and dedicates some of the later pieces to the hope they provide. While these pieces are more jaunty than the others, it would be difficult to call them cheerful; “Fragile Hope” seems more authentic than “Eye of Newt,” simply because the mind may not be ready to encounter more than soft, gentle encouragement. Those reading the track titles can see the arc tilting toward the wrenching “Things I Would Have Done With You,” a specific mourning made universal.
Lucy Claire deserves acclaim not only for baring her soul, but for resisting the happy ending. It’s all too easy for others to say, “You have a child now” and to forget those who have come before. A mother always remembers. (Richard Allen)
